Sections

The Complex Origins of Whale Hearing

The Complex Origins of Whale Hearing

06.08.2017, by
Humpback whale and its offspring (Megaptera novaeanglia), Indian Ocean, Réunion island.
A new fossil study brings us one crucial step closer to retracing the evolution of the auditory capacities of cetaceans, the mammal group namely comprising whales. An issue that intrigues scientists as present-day whales exhibit two distinctive ways of producing and hearing sound.

The otherworldly clicks and whistles of whale song are largely inaudible to human ears as their frequencies are either too low or too high for us to hear. Too low in the case of baleen whales—cetaceans that filter food like krill from seawater with the baleen plates in their mouths—whose infrasounds enable long-distance communication. Too high in the case of toothed whales—fish-hunting cetaceans including dolphins, porpoises, and sperm whales—which emit ultrasounds whose echoes allow them to locate and identify objects. In both cases, incredible auditory abilities whose evolutionary origins remain murky as scientists have puzzled over whether primitive whales started off by hearing low- or high-frequency sounds. Now, by probing into 45-million-year-old fossil specimens, a pair of French paleontologists has reconstructed the cochlear structure of protocetids, a now-vanished group of early cetaceans, to paint a new picture of how whale hearing ability developed.1

3D model of the internal cavity of the inner ear, including the cochlea.

About
Close
Description: 
modèle 3D de la cavité interne du labyrinthe osseux, comportant la cochlée.
Année de production: 
2017
Réalisateur: 
M.J MOURLAM/MorphoMuseum

From legs to fins

A bit of family history first. Roughly 40 million years ago, baleen and toothed whales evolved from a common ancestor. “But as we have no physical traces of it,” explains Maeva Orliac of the ISEM,2 “its identity remains purely theoretical.” In order to find out more about today’s whales, Orliac and fellow ISEM paleontologist Mickaël Mourlam thus looked at the protocetids, “an extinct cousin group of present-day cetaceans.” While the amphibious protocetids had four limbs for dwelling on land and water, whales—once legged creatures—would eventually shed their hind legs while their front legs evolved into fins. On the basis of this shared legged past, both however fall in the broad mammal group of the even-toed ungulates that encompasses cows, pigs, hippopotamuses, giraffes, camels, and whose “transition from terrestrial to aquatic habitats is the core of the team’s research focus.”

Researchers looked at protocetids, an extinct cousin group of present-day cetaceans.

Orliac recounts that the project kicked off “when the Université de Montpellier recently recovered a set of protocetid fossils, extracted from deposits in Togo in the 1970-80s. “There are very few of them around,” the researcher continues, “and access to those that exist is sometimes jealously guarded!” So when the fossils—representing two out of the three protocetid species identified in the Togo deposits—arrived in France, the paleontologists naturally seized the opportunity to investigate the ongoing debate on whether the whale’s primitive relatives were more sensitive to high or low frequencies.

The team proceeded by running the two fossil samples—a cranial fragment and a bone surrounding the inner ear—through a micro-computed tomography scanner. Orliac explains that “the scanner’s very powerful X-rays can detect the fossil’s different densities and distinguish between rock and fossilized bone.” As a result, the scans provided cross-section images of the samples while keeping them intact. 

The researchers’ next challenge was to use the scans to reconstruct the protocetids’ bony labyrinth—the inner ear’s hard outer wall containing the spiral-shaped cochlea cavity with the organ that responds to sound. Reconstruction proved laborious. “We examined thousands of images,” recalls Orliac, “because the extremely dense ear bone meant that they were unclear and difficult to work with.” But the scientists finally met their goal, and produced “a virtual 3D mold of the animal’s cochlea.” And significantly, to lift the secrecy surrounding these rare fossils, the French paleontologists are making public all of their 3D models.

Fossilized bone of Carolinacetus sp. found in Togo.
Fossilized bone of Carolinacetus sp. found in Togo.

So what exactly do the models tell us? While Orliac admits that “it’s impossible to establish which frequency range protocetids could hear, the results clearly show what they couldn’t hear.” In this way, the research duo is now “positive that the protocetids heard neither ultrasounds nor infrasounds,” settling the debate on whether primitive cetaceans had the capacity to hear one or the other. 

The protocetids’ less specialized auditory capacities however allowed them to hear both in water and on land. Of particular note, their cochlear structure turns out to resemble that of their terrestrial even-toed ungulate relatives. But for the ISEM researcher, this outcome is not altogether surprising: “It’s very logical that animals with legs were close to their terrestrial cousins. After all, they had to be operational on land too.” 

The scanner’s very powerful X-rays can detect the fossil’s different densities and distinguish between rock and fossilized bone.

This discovery implies that infrasound and ultrasound communication in whales developed later than once believed, after whales had turned fully aquatic and separated into the toothed and baleen branches. What also emerges is that whale evolution is more complex than previously thought. The French researchers hope to fill in more gaps by returning to Togo at the end of 2017. Their aim? To find head-bone remains of the third protocetid species in order to compare its hearing system to the two now-examined species. Orliac is keen to explore “how the hearing capacities of the different species vary.”

But the team’s research interests also spread further afield. Orliac and her colleague anticipate “going back further in history and studying the auditory regions of even more primitive animals, more terrestrial ones, such as the Choeropotamus that resembled a small hippo.”

Footnotes
  • 1. M.J. Mourlam & M.J. Orliac, “Infrasonic and Ultrasonic Hearing Evolved after the Emergence of Modern Whales,” Current Biology (2017). http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.cub.2017.04.061.
  • 2. Institut des Sciences de l’Evolution de Montpellier (CNRS / Institut de Recherche pour le Développement / Université de Montpellier).
Go further

Author

Fui Lee Luk

As well as contributing to the CNRSNews, Fui Lee Luk is a freelance translator for various publishing houses and websites. She has a PhD in French literature (Paris III / University of Sydney).

Comments

13 comments

My name is Bryan Johnson am from South America I want the general public, to know how this great man called Doctor Disu cure me and my sister from GENITAL HERPES with the herbal medicine gotten from him, And i have confirmed that he cures other diseases too like STD, SYPHILIS, CANCER, PARKINSON DISEASE, DIABETES, Herpes, Mine was worst I have suffered from Human papillama virus HPV) for 3years he cure me too!!! herbal medication is a great medication. he have a medicine that is 100% assured to cure any type of disease and you don't need to spend so much money anymore. I want you to contact Doctor Disu via Email:africanherbalcure@gmail.com My family is now a brand new one, so stop your worries and go get your herbal medicine now to get your family free from deadly disease. Once again thanks to Doctor Disu.

Herpes simplex virus 2 causes herpes type 2 or genital herpes. This infection causes sores in the genital area of men and women .Herpes simplex virus 1 causes herpes type 1 or cold sores, also known as orofacial herpes. This infection affects the mouth and the skin. There will be blistering sores in the mouth and in different parts of the body.You All please listen to my story that has brought back my happiness, I am here to express my profound warm gratitude to the Natural Herbal Medicine, which i got from DR.SANDY,after 6 days of communication he sent some herbal medicines to me. I am now leaving a healthy life since the past 9months after the completion of my Genital and Oral Herpes treatment with the DR.SANDY Natural Healing Medicine, i am now completely Herpes Free, after the application and usage of DR.SANDY Medicine. Currently the only cure for Herpes, Cancer,Diabetes and every other Human diseases is DR.SANDY Herbal Medicine. As i am A living witness of this great miracle, you can save more patient from pharmaceutical scandals by sharing or contacting this great Natural healer for the Medication also call him on Whatsapp +2349031726182 Let Stop Herpes with DR.SANDY Herbal Medicine. Let`s save life by sharing this on all social network as God will bless you as you share this information that will give every Herpes patient’s a hope for a new Life. and via this email. dr.sandyspelltemple@gmail.com dr.sandyspelltemple@hotmail.com dr.sandyspelltemple@yahoo.com OR call Whats App Number +2349031726182 https://web.facebook.com/Drsandy-SPELL-HOME-2-226270587825982/ and he have cure for this HPV ALS HSV Thanks for your Time and i hope you tell people about this herbal medicine......

I was diagnosed with Parkinson's disease a year ago at the age of 68. For several months I had noticed tremors in my right hand and the shaking of my right foot when I was sitting. My normally beautiful cursive writing was now small cramped printing. And I tended to lose my balance. Neurologist had me walk down the hall and said I didn't swing my right arm. I had never noticed! I was in denial for a while as there is no history in my family of parents and five older siblings, but now accept I had classic symptoms. I was taking pramipexole (Sifrol), carbidopa/levodopa and Biperiden, 2 mg. and started physical therapy to strengthen muscles. nothing was really working to help my condition.I went off the Siferol (with the doctor’s knowledge) and started on parkinson’s herbal formula i ordered from Health Herbal Clinic, my symptoms totally declined over a 5 weeks use of the Parkinsons disease natural herbal formula. i am now almost 70 and doing very well, the disease is totally reversed!! Visit there website www . healthherbalclinic . net

Hello all,A short comment from the Netherlands. My name is Richard 46 year old, fantastic live till december 2013, now livibg in hell and Pain I am currently on my two weeks of treatment for prostatitis epididimytis calcification and Herpes 2. I had a lump on my testicle,Herpes or swollen prostate, and shooting pains on my whole right side (which urologists in the US said was unrelated LOL). Anyways it took me a year to finally make the decision to come here and get treated and needless the say the Doctor Sandy saved my life. If you have Herpes or swollen prostate , you definitely have an infection. Oral antibiotics do nothing and neither does diet. If your first round of antibiotics failed the prostate and the Herpes starts forming calcification around the infection and this needs to be addressed as well. This is the Only clinic in the world that has Dr.Sandy herbal medicine to address and break up the calcification. You need to be here to use the herbal medicine 14 to 16 day depending on your Herpes or swollen prostate to become calcification . I am only writing this because I had read some of the comments here and want to state the truth. If your prostate symptoms or your Herpes 2 have not resolved after first course of treatment you will need to have this treatment of Dr.Sandy Herpes Medicine, please don’t use doctors that go through the rectum it is dangerous and will spread bacteria and the infection will only come back if the calcification is not treated as well. I will leave my email and Dr.Sandy email and whatsapp number so will respond as best as I can. I am not disclosing the name of the clinic publicly but will do so by email or phone. Please don’t hesitate as I want to help as many people as I can because I’ve been through the suffering. Good luck to you all on this journey and if you are looking for a cure email me or Dr.Sandy asap. dr.sandyspelltemple@gmail.com dr.sandyspelltemple@hotmail.com dr.sandyspelltemple@yahoo.com OR call Whats App Number +2349031726182 https://web.facebook.com/Drsandy-SPELL-HOME-2-226270587825982/ SIR GOD WILL BLESS YOU FOR ALL THE HELP ON ME AND MY FAMILY, THANK YOU SIR.......

Hello all,A short comment from the Netherlands. My name is Richard 46 year old, fantastic live till december 2013, now livibg in hell and Pain I am currently on my two weeks of treatment for prostatitis epididimytis calcification and Herpes 2. I had a lump on my testicle,Herpes or swollen prostate, and shooting pains on my whole right side (which urologists in the US said was unrelated LOL). Anyways it took me a year to finally make the decision to come here and get treated and needless the say the Doctor Sandy saved my life. If you have Herpes or swollen prostate , you definitely have an infection. Oral antibiotics do nothing and neither does diet. If your first round of antibiotics failed the prostate and the Herpes starts forming calcification around the infection and this needs to be addressed as well. This is the Only clinic in the world that has Dr.Sandy herbal medicine to address and break up the calcification. You need to be here to use the herbal medicine 14 to 16 day depending on your Herpes or swollen prostate to become calcification . I am only writing this because I had read some of the comments here and want to state the truth. If your prostate symptoms or your Herpes 2 have not resolved after first course of treatment you will need to have this treatment of Dr.Sandy Herpes Medicine, please don’t use doctors that go through the rectum it is dangerous and will spread bacteria and the infection will only come back if the calcification is not treated as well. I will leave my email and Dr.Sandy email and whatsapp number so will respond as best as I can. I am not disclosing the name of the clinic publicly but will do so by email or phone. Please don’t hesitate as I want to help as many people as I can because I’ve been through the suffering. Good luck to you all on this journey and if you are looking for a cure email me or Dr.Sandy asap. dr.sandyspelltemple@gmail.com dr.sandyspelltemple@hotmail.com dr.sandyspelltemple@yahoo.com OR call Whats App Number +2349031726182 https://web.facebook.com/Drsandy-SPELL-HOME-2-226270587825982/ SIR GOD WILL BLESS YOU FOR ALL THE HELP ON ME AND MY FAMILY, THANK YOU SIR.......

Hi Friends i am so glad to writing this article today to tell the world how my HIV VIRUS was cured,i have been detected with HIV AIDS since five years ago, ever since then my life has been in complete bizarre and agony,i have used so many drugs that was prescribed to me by several doctors,but it didn't cure my HIV VIRUS neither did it reduce the pain,until a certain day i was checking for solution in the internet,then miraculously came across Dr. Ebose the powerful herbalist that cure numerous individuals HIV AIDS INFECTION,then i contacted his email: ebosespelltemple@gmail.com i explained everything to him and prepared a cure that cure my HIV disease totally after receiving his herbal medicine, so my friends viewer s why wait and suffer when there is someone like Dr Ebose that can cure any disease HIV/ CANCER/ HEPATITIS B VIRUS, you can contact via email: ebosespelltemple@gmail.com, call or whatsapp him with any of the moible number +2349059611566 or +2348160157518

Hi Friends i am so glad to writing this article today to tell the world how my HIV VIRUS was cured,i have been detected with HIV AIDS since five years ago, ever since then my life has been in complete bizarre and agony,i have used so many drugs that was prescribed to me by several doctors,but it didn't cure my HIV VIRUS neither did it reduce the pain,until a certain day i was checking for solution in the internet,then miraculously came across Dr. Ebose the powerful herbalist that cure numerous individuals HIV AIDS INFECTION,then i contacted his email: ebosespelltemple@gmail.com i explained everything to him and prepared a cure that cure my HIV disease totally after receiving his herbal medicine, so my friends viewer s why wait and suffer when there is someone like Dr Ebose that can cure any disease HIV/ CANCER/ HEPATITIS B VIRUS, you can contact via email: ebosespelltemple@gmail.com, call or whatsapp him with any of the moible number +2349059611566 or +2348160157518

Suffering from herpes is a Terrible Experience which i suffered till i meet a herbal doctor called Dr Atakuma. I tried Herbs from some Herbal Doctors by communicating with them but i never received cure.Just about few month ago i saw a recent post of how Dr Atakuma's herbs has cured so many people and that he is a honest man to work with in the procedures on finding a cure. Then i contacted him in trial and the Herbs he Sent me got me Cured after two weeks.I am so happy that i am free.my advice to the world please dont mind the scientific reserch only try and also beleive is herbal medicine cause most disease can be cure with HERBS.here is the Dr's email dr.atakumaoracle@outlook.com dr.atakumaoracle@outlook.com You can also add him up on whatsapp via+2347064693371 +2347064693371

Am here to appreciate Dr Aba for using his herbal medicine to cure my Herpes virus. since 3 years now I have been living with this virus and it has been giving me challenges, I was so perplexed cause i have been taking several drugs to be cured but all of my effort was in vain,one morning i was browsing through the internet then i saw several testimonies about Dr. Aba curing people from Herpes virus and immediately i contacted Dr. Aba on his email: dr.abaherbalhome@gmail.com, i told him about my troubles and he told me that i must be cured, gave me some instructions and which i rightly followed. so he prepared a herbal medicine for me and sent it to me which i used for 2 weeks and everything was like a dream to me and my Herpes virus was totally gone,. why don't you contact him today and be free from your diseases because he is very good and honest Doctor. contact him via email; dr.abaherbalhome@gmail.com or whatsApp him on +2348107155060

I was cured of HIV with the used of natural herbs. My name is Charlotte Martha and am from US. I love herbs so much. Most times, injection and drugs are just a waste of time. I was cured 8months ago, i suffered from HIV for 13yrs but with the help of Dr.UDU herbal medicine, i was cured within few weeks of drinking the herbs he sent to me through courier delivery service. This same doctor also cured my Aunty from herpes, as soon as i heard she had herpes, i quickly refer her to Dr.Udu and she was cured too after drinking his herbs.I have referred more than 15 persons to Dr.Udu and they were all cured from their various illness. Have you taken herbs before?. You have spent so much money on drugs,injections,surgeries etc and yet you have no good result to show for it. Contact Dr.Udu now, he is a herbalist doctor, i assured you of a cure if you drink his natural herbs. Dr.Udu have herbs that cures HIV,HERPES SIMPLEX Virus, Diabetics, Asthma, Hepatitis, HBP, STD, Cancer, Chronic, etc. Contact Dr Udu through his Email address on: udusolutionhouse@gmail.com Please share the good news to other people once you are cured, health is wealth

Pages

To comment on this article,
Log in, join the CNRS News community